Showing posts with label Sixth Circuit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sixth Circuit. Show all posts

Friday, June 12, 2015

SCOTUS Okaying Gay Marriage Is Not Bad Law, It's Not Law at All



Within the month, the nation will receive the opinion of the U.S. Supreme Court as to whether the U.S. Constitution requires all of the states to jettison their domestic laws and sanction same-sex marriage.  Numerous federal judges have so ruled, and most states have simply yielded to those federal court decisions.  In a few cases, beginning with Vermont and Massachusetts, state courts ruled for same-sex marriage, and state officials have accepted passively those decisions as well. 
Generally, courts have ruled for same-sex marriage using either the “due process clause” or the “equal protection clause” of the Fourteenth Amendment, or both.  That raises a simple question:  is it really possible that when the Fourteenth Amendment was ratified in 1868 the framers intended that it sanction same-sex marriage?  Of course not.  The U.S. Constitution says nothing about same-sex marriage.  Then, how could the Constitution be manipulated to support a decision in favor of same-sex marriage?  Well it has not been easy.  The Constitutional case for same-sex marriage is pathetically weak — unless you adopt the notion of an “evolving” Constitution — which is, of course, the polar opposite of the notion of our “written” Constitution. 
There are actually four cases, all from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, which have been consolidated for decision in the U.S. Supreme Court — ObergefellDeBoerTanco, and Bourke.  If you would like to know more about how this case developed, a great deal of information, and links to all documents, is available on SCOTUSblog.  The amicus curiae brief which we filed in the Sixth Circuit in support of traditional marriage is available, as is the amicus curiae brief which we filed in the U.S. Supreme Court

Popular Posts